broderbund american greetings creatacard select 6

However, the court held that a sequence of menu screens, forming a ' user interface,' was copyrightable, noting 'stylistic creativity' in the screens beyond the basic instructions conveyed by them. The bottom line is that the designer of any program that performed the same functions as 'Print Shop' had available a wide range of expression governed predominantly by artistic and not utilitarian considerations. He could have written: 'Select a Font,' or 'Indicate a Typeface Preference,' or 'Which Type Style Do You Prefer,' or any combination of these terms. On the 'Choose a Font' screen, no mechanical or practical factor compelled to use those exact words ('Choose a Font'). In rejecting the argument that the functionality of the program dictated the expression of its user interface, the district court noted that: While the plaintiff originally made a number of claims pertaining to its greeting card application program called 'The Print Shop,' only the question of infringement of the audiovisual copyright in the screen displays was tried to the court.

Jaslow, of protecting the program's structure, sequence, organization, but the court applied and extended this principle to the protection of the program's visual displays. The district court followed the precedent set in Whelan v.

Broderbund american greetings creatacard select 6